News · Politics & Accountability · Philadelphia, PA
Philadelphia Council committee votes to drop Reworld incinerator from city trash contracts
A Philadelphia City Council committee voted unanimously Wednesday to strip the Reworld trash incinerator in Chester from the city's proposed waste disposal contracts, a move that would end the practice of burning a share of Philadelphia's garbage in the Delaware County city if it survives a full Council vote.
FOX 29 reported the Committee on the Environment's vote was 6-0. The committee amended an ordinance that would have let Mayor Cherelle Parker's sanitation department sign three disposal contracts, removing Reworld while keeping new landfill agreements with WM and Republic Services, according to WHYY and FOX 29.
Outlets described the length of the rejected deal somewhat differently. 6abc said the proposal would have kept the current arrangement for four years with an annual renewal option for three more, while FOX 29 and CBS Philadelphia described a seven-year deal. The incinerator handles roughly a third of the city's trash, the outlets reported. The current contracts expire at year's end, WHYY reported.
Councilmember Jamie Gauthier, who chairs the committee and has pushed legislation to bar incineration contracts, told CBS Philadelphia the administration could send that portion of trash to landfills while working to reduce waste. "We have ended our practice of burning trash in Chester," Gauthier said, according to WHYY.
The vote followed more than four hours of testimony, CBS Philadelphia reported. Chester Health Commissioner Kristin Motley testified that her city has elevated rates of childhood asthma and other illnesses, calling the incinerator a major contributor to pollution, according to WHYY. Chester Mayor Stefan Roots said Reworld pays the financially distressed city about $5 million a year but that the plant hampers waterfront redevelopment, 6abc reported.
FOX 29 reported that a former Reworld employee testified about aging pollution monitoring equipment, and that advocates cited hundreds of violations and nearly $1 million in fines over two decades.
Reworld representatives said the facility operates safely and within environmental limits. Jyoti Agarwal, the company's director of environmental programs, cited a third-party health risk assessment showing risks below thresholds of concern, WHYY reported.
Parker administration officials defended the contract. Managing Director Carlton Williams said Chester's air quality was comparable to nearby areas and estimated a landfill-only approach would cost about $15 million more over four years, according to WHYY. Gauthier countered that the city would still save money compared with current contracts. "Were we to stop sending our waste to Chester, we'd have to put more trucks on the road," Williams said, according to 6abc.
The full Council could vote as early as Dec. 3, according to 6abc and WHYY. FOX 29 reported the measure is expected to pass there but could face a mayoral veto. A city official told 6abc the city is considering all of its options.
Compiled by True News from reporting by 6abc Action News, CBS Philadelphia, FOX 29 Philadelphia and WHYY. Each outlet's original story is linked below.
Sources
- Philadelphia City Council committee advances sanitation contract amid Chester incinerator debate (6abc Action News)
- Philadelphia City Council committee moves to stop sending city's trash to Chester, Pennsylvania (CBS Philadelphia)
- Philly City Council’s environment committee votes to stop sending trash to Chester incinerator (FOX 29 Philadelphia)
- Philadelphia City Council committee rejects controversial contract with Reworld incinerator (WHYY)
Get stories like this every morning
The True News daily briefing: who's funding your officials, the economy in plain numbers, missing persons and community stories. Free, one email a day, unsubscribe in one click.